Naqvi warns minister over criticism amid new provinces debate
Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi issued a stern public warning to a fellow cabinet member over persistent criticism, defending business leaders and highlighting coalition tensions over governance reforms and the creation of new provinces.

Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi has warned a fellow cabinet member against repeated criticism, stating he has shown patience for two and a half years and will not tolerate further public remarks. Naqvi made the comments during an informal conversation with journalists in Lahore on Sunday, though he did not name the critic he warned.
Naqvi described the criticism as persistent and said he had exercised restraint throughout the tenure of the incumbent government since the 2024 elections. He warned his silence should not be mistaken for an inability to respond. "The day I comment on this minister, he will not be able to show his face," Naqvi said. He accused the unnamed federal minister of criticizing him on television daily in an apparent bid to attract public attention.
Naqvi defends businessmen at economic forum
At the Pakistan Economic Summit in Islamabad in July, Naqvi defended business leaders as respectable citizens and major taxpayers. He stated these individuals had served as presidents and office-bearers of chambers of commerce at the federal level and in various cities across Pakistan. Naqvi claimed these business figures are among the country’s highest taxpayers.
He questioned why political parties collect billions of rupees from these same businessmen in the name of party funding during every election. Naqvi's remarks at the forum included a proposal for a new governance system and the creation of new provinces, arguing the existing model had collapsed after decades of failing to deliver. He stated decentralisation was essential to improve public services, ensure timely justice, and create youth opportunities.
Sanaullah challenges Naqvi's provincial debate origins
Inter-Provincial Coordination Minister Rana Sanaullah, Naqvi’s predecessor, accused Naqvi of initiating the new provinces discussion at the economic forum rather than in Parliament. Sanaullah said the matter worsened so much that the debate on provinces started from an economic forum, calling it an unnecessary escalation. He contended the debate on provinces was not wrong but was being entangled with other issues, including claims that the system had collapsed and remarks about the prime minister and election contestants.
Sanaullah clarified he was not referring to all businesspeople but to a few who commit crimes in business. He said politicians could express opinions on new provinces, but regimental discipline could not be enforced in the cabinet. In September, Sanaullah said the debate on new provinces should have started in Parliament, not in speeches, social media, seminars, or business forums.
Sanaullah also criticized PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari for complicating the situation with a November 17 speech, which raised various matters beyond opposing new provinces from Sindh. He referred to both Bilawal and Naqvi as political figures close to President Asif Ali Zardari. Sanaullah reported a recent meeting at the President House attended by President Zardari, Bilawal, and Naqvi, where an understanding was reached to reduce tensions. He stated a ceasefire was decided during a meeting between President Zardari and Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, with Naqvi present.
Coalition tensions rise over governance reforms
The dispute reflects broader disagreements within the ruling coalition on decentralisation, provincial creation, and the role of business interests in governance. Defence Minister Khawaja Asif, a PML-N leader, agreed with Naqvi's assessment of systemic shortcomings but said reform should occur through parliament or the federal cabinet. Asif noted Naqvi had held influential positions for three and a half years and could have raised systemic reform issues during that time.
Inter-Services Public Relations (ISPR) Director General Lt Gen Ahmed Sharif Chaudhry endorsed Naqvi's call for an administrative reset for good governance. Meanwhile, Sindh Local Government Minister Nasir Hussain Shah rejected Sanaullah’s remarks about Bilawal, stating Bilawal was the only son of President Zardari. Shah said Mohsin Naqvi was worthy of respect but nothing about him compared to Bilawal, and that only Bilawal’s words would prevail.
Naqvi has held some of the country's most influential positions over the past three and a half years. His recent remarks came amid criticism following his proposal for new governance and provinces. The interior minister warned that his patience should not be mistaken for an inability to respond.





