Kerala High Court dismisses contempt petition over judge's remarks
The Kerala High Court dismissed lawyer T.B. Mini's petition seeking contempt proceedings against a district judge for alleged remarks made during the 2017 actress assault case trial, ruling that media reports and hearsay cannot form the basis for such action.

The Kerala High Court dismissed lawyer T.B. Mini’s petition on Tuesday, November 18, 2026. The petition sought contempt proceedings against District Judge Honey M. Varghese over alleged remarks made during the 2017 actress assault case trial.
Justice P V Kunhikrishnan presided over the case, TB Mini v The Hon'ble Registrar General & ors. The court dismissed the plea on the grounds that judicial officers cannot be proceeded against based on hearsay accounts of alleged statements not part of official records. Justice Kunhikrishnan observed that Mini's claim about the judge's remarks was based on media reports, not official court documents. The judge also noted that Mini was not present when the remarks were allegedly made.
Petition details and allegations
T B Mini, a lawyer representing the survivor in the 2017 case, filed the petition. She alleged that on January 12, 2026, Judge Varghese made defamatory remarks in open court. The judge allegedly stated that Mini attended fewer than 10 days of the trial, stayed in court for only half an hour, and slept during proceedings. Mini disputed these claims, asserting she attended for more than 200 days, including witness examination and arguments.
The alleged remarks were reportedly circulated by television channels and social media. Mini argued this led to public criticism and attacks on her professional reputation. Her petition sought multiple remedies. It requested initiation of contempt proceedings against the judge, deletion of the remarks from court records, an official clarification, removal of related media reports, and directions to prevent further publication. The petition was filed through advocate K Nandini.
Mini first approached the Chief Justice of the Kerala High Court and later the Advocate General of Kerala for sanction to initiate criminal contempt proceedings. The Advocate General rejected the request on April 22 of this year, citing insufficient materials. The AG concluded the alleged statements did not warrant a criminal contempt case, characterizing them as excessive or extravagant language rather than contemptuous. Mini later appealed this decision, arguing the Advocate General failed to assess submitted materials properly.
Court's reasoning on jurisdiction and evidence
The High Court's dismissal was firmly rooted in jurisdictional and evidential principles. The bench ruled that contempt proceedings cannot be initiated against a judicial officer based solely on media reports or hearsay. Justice Kunhikrishnan found there was no material to establish the judge made the remarks, as the junior lawyer who allegedly heard them had not made a formal statement in court.
The court emphasized that remarks made by judges during proceedings should not be circulated outside the courtroom. It stated that oral observations by judges and lawyers should not be treated as news, especially when such reporting could harm the dignity and reputation of the parties involved. Judges speak through their judgments, not courtroom dialogue. The court noted that the media organizations involved were not made parties to the petition and therefore refrained from commenting further on their role.
The High Court agreed with the Advocate General's view that harsh or inappropriate language during court proceedings does not automatically constitute criminal contempt. It also observed that Mini had been practicing law for several years with no prior complaints about her competence. The trial in question concluded in December 2025 with the conviction of Pulsar Suni and five others; actor Dileep was acquitted of all charges.
Additional Advocate General PA Mohammed Shah represented the State in the hearing. The court concluded by directing Mini to ignore social media comments and continue her professional duties. It stated she would be rewarded one day for her work.





